Both sociologist Pierre Bourdieu (1930-2002) and social psychologist Karl Weick (1936- ) made outstanding contributions to helping us think insightfully about human action in real life: in conditions of limited time, patchy understanding and pre-existing commitments to important stakes. This article in the International Journal of Learning and Change uses and compares the two approaches, to re-think what happens when executives are selected to fill senior positions in industries and environments far from the ones in which they learned their skills.